Saturday, November 15, 2014

A631.4.4.RB – INSEAD Reflection

What do you see as some of the major benefits and drawbacks of self-managed teams?
To understand self-managed teams; it is important to find an acceptable definition.  Self-managed teams are a group of employees that are responsible and accountable for all or most aspects of producing a product or delivering a service.  Self-managed teams are provided an increased responsibility of ownership of the tasks they are assigned.  One of the biggest benefits of a self-managed team is the cross training developmental opportunities that occur when an individual has to fill in when team members are absent.  The decision making process normally involves less conflict between the team members because they make the decisions and agree upon how to accomplish task.  The individuals who decide on the task are the ones who accomplish the job.  The last benefit that I feel I need to discuss is team cohesion.  Self-managed teams are able to truly succeed and fail as a team, which can promote teamwork and relationship-building.
However, there are some drawbacks to self-managed teams.  One of the biggest problems I have seen is groupthink; “the go along to get along mentality” that results in an accelerated, false consensus.  Another drawback associated with self-managed teams is that the decision-making process may take longer to finalize as compared to when there is no authority figure.  One fact that must be kept in perspective is self-managed teams still require leadership.  This leader is usually appointed to guide the team through the decision-making process, acting much like a chairperson for a committee.  Last but not least is the fact that self-managed teams are prone to personality clashes and without a strong leadership presence the team can quickly breakdown.
 
Would you like to work within such a team?
Knowing my personality style, I have not always had the best experience with the concept of a self-managed team.  I am a person who needs structure, clear direction, and well established parameters.  However if it were the right group of individuals, I think it would be an interesting experience to be part of a self-managed team that relates to my career aspirations. By keeping an open mind, I feel being a member of such a team would not only enable me share my experiences, it would also allow me to learn new techniques to grow as a professional.    
 
What competencies would you need to develop to be an effective external manager of a self-managed work team?
At first I was wondering why a person needs competence to manage a self-managed team.  Then I think back to the self-managed teams I have had to assemble for special projects and I realized that self-managed teams are not without leadership.  When you really think about it, the role of the leader in self-managing teams is vital to the team’s success, because this team will be a standalone entity with a lot of self-imposed accountability and responsibility.  Without a doubt, the first and foremost skill needed is the ability to communicate clearly and concisely.  Before a team is established as a self-managed team, it must be given direction and guidance.  This is done when the external manager clearly communicates with the team and establishes organizational goals.  Once the initial communication process is done, the job of the external manager is not done.  He or she must have the foresight to delegate responsibilities to the team members and give them the opportunity to do the job they have been given.  In other words, the external managers must delegate and give the team the authority to make decisions.  Let them learn from their successes and failures.  As retired General Stanley McCrystal once said his boss taught him, “A good leader will let his subordinates fail without letting them become failures.   

 

No comments:

Post a Comment